What are you looking for?

Concluded
Fruit and veg

Controlling water imbalances to reduce tomato losses

Supported by:

The research

Tomato growers in the Isle of Wight and Yorkshire hope to considerably reduce waste from splitting and blossom end rot, which can cause yield losses of up to 10%. These are physiological issues affected by water, temperature, light and ventilation, which affect the uptake of water in the plants. Water balance sensors have been developed by industry to give insights into how plants respond to these growing conditions, but the technology has rarely been tested in UK glasshouses. The plan was to use this information to adapt the glasshouse environment to reduce stress on the plant with the hope that this will reduce fruit disease.

In this field lab, growers installed these sensors in non-organic beef and cherry tomatoes and organic piccolo tomatoes, with the plan to build a continuous picture of stem diameter and sap flow within the plants. It is hoped the findings can be applied to many other protected crops including peppers, cucumbers, and soft fruit, as well as with outdoor annual and perennial crops.

The benefits

Blossom end rot is caused by insufficient calcium reaching tomato tissue. Incorrect water balance together with suboptimal light, ventilation and humidity can lead to a shortfall of calcium in the plant, particularly at the end of the fruit, making it unmarketable. 

Similarly, sudden fluxes in temperature and irrigation can cause tomatoes to split, particularly when combined with a period of unstable light conditions, affecting transpiration. By using the data generated by the sensors, farmers can adjust greenhouse conditions and irrigation to reduce stress.

Trial Design


Three sets of sensors will be installed after an initial proof of concept trial and testing of equipment in the following 3 tomato cropping situations at 3 sites (6 farmers);

  1. Speciality beef tomato crop grown on the Isle of Wight: The crop will be grown in coco husk (coir) media and ‘conventional’ fertigation used. The sensor will first be deployed into a crop grown under lights, which historically has suffered badly with BER.
  2. Piccolo cherry tomato grown at a tomato production site in the Alderley Edge (Cheshire) which is prone to fruit splitting. The crop would be grown in rockwool (a basalt growing media) and conventional fertigation used.
  3. Piccolo cherry tomato grown on the Isle of Wight with significant fruit splitting issues as the above. This is a soil grown organic crop presenting greater challenges when considering the optimisation of water supply. 

Although it may not be possible to have a meaningful control within the working crops during the trials work, the figures for crop losses stated are relatively stable year on year. Thus, comparison with previous years data regarding fruit splitting and BER will be used as the best and most meaningful comparison we can use. 

Data from the novel water sensors will be collected continuously to include sap flow and stem diameter provided by the 2Grow system and also measurements of moisture content, humidity deficit, vapour pressure deficit, leaf surface temperature, air temperature, heating pipe temperature, air exchange, vent position and other parameters collected by our existing environmental computers

Latest updates
Nov 30 2021

Final report produced

For the full report please see the reports and results section of the field lab page.

The group met and consolidated and reviewed the last eight weeks data. The key points are:

  • We were not able to pick up the situation where blossom end rot occurs in the beef tomato in advance of it actually happening.
  • There are a number of situations at the site in Yorkshire where the irrigation starting strategy could be improved (either earlier or later).
  • Investigations are being made into automating the starting of irrigation in relation to EC, sap flow, stem diameter and water content.

Other actions:

  • We should have a new widget to allow a faster interpretation of the data
  • We will send plant data to 2Grow (the sensor company) to see if any relation can be seen with shrinking/ increasing stems with flowering speed
  • Investigate if ‘dangerous’ occurrences can be marked or alarms set.

The sensors have been fitted on the beef and piccolo tomato crops on the Isle of Wight and the cherry tomato crop at the site near Hull. The sensors were fitted when tomato plant stems exceeded 10mm thickness. There have been some issues with getting the stem diameter sensor at the Yorkshire site fitted correctly. This is now in place and reading well. They have seen some ‘knocks’ to the sensors during the weekly crop husbandry. Although these are frustrating all sensors have been adjusted and reading correctly.

The growers have weekly virtual meetings with the sensor providers to discuss learnings and also maintain an active WhatsApp group for immediate feedback regarding unexpected spikes or drops in sap flow or stem diameter occur.

Just a couple of weeks after the sensors were installed into the beef tomato crop, the sensors have enabled the growers to identify some crucial areas to make adjustments:

  • Night screens help avoid light escaping from artificial light in greenhouses and causing night pollution. In the mornings, this is removed. The growers identified that they had been removing the night screen too fast, which decreased transpiration (the sensors showed that stem diameter increased and flow reduced). They believe the stomata were closing as cold air hit the plants when the screen was removed. They have slowed down removal and are seeing less scorch.
  • They are able to keep stem diameter more constant than previously by watering earlier in the day

Sensors will be fitted onto the piccolo crop and cherry tomato crop in late February

• Reduce splitting in Piccolo vine
--> Ensuring the irrigation is applied at the right time
--> Ensuring that the supply is in line with transpiration

• Reduce Blossom End Rot (BER) in beef tomatoes CV Jack Hawkins
--> Ensuring that the plant has enough water at all times
--> Ensuring that the plant is able to recover at the end of the day

Locations: 
Farms located in Yorkshire and the Isle of Wight

Technology:
• Stem diameter and sap flow sensors
• Used to indicate physiological water imbalances in real time
• Growers and data analysis specialists have constant access to the technology and offer advice as part of their service

Group communication:
• Fortnightly catch ups and presentations on progress
• Whatsapp group

Sensors fitted to beef crop

5th January 2021

All sensors fitted to tomato crops

15th March 2021

Ongoing refinement of climate and irrigation settings

From 15th March 2021

Final report and next steps

30th November 2021

Group Coordinator

A portrait of Brian Moralee.
Brian Moralee

APS Produce

Isle of Wight

Brian is a grower manager on the Isle of Wight at APS Produce, part of the APS Group. His wider grower network includes members of the British Tomato Growers Association, the Tomato Working Party and the Tomato Study Group.

Download the final report